British, American and other international owners of French property often elect the law of their nationality to govern their succession. Under Article 22 of Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 (the EU Succession Regulation), that professio juris can apply to the estate as a whole — including assets situated in France. For years, many assumed this was enough to step outside French forced heirship (réserve héréditaire).

Since 1 November 2021, that assumption has needed a second filter: the compensatory levy in Article 913, paragraph 3 of the French Civil Code (Law No 2021-1109 of 24 August 2021). Where the deceased or at least one child has an EU nationality or habitual residence in the EU, and the foreign succession law allows no child-protective reserve mechanism, each child may claim a compensatory levy on assets located in France, up to the French reserved share.

What changed in June 2026

On 4 June 2026 the European Commission published France’s official explanations in the pre-closure notice for multiple complaint CPLT(2022)03325. The French authorities stated that:

  • the statute targets foreign laws that allow no “reserve mechanism protective of children”, not only the French réserve as such;
  • Anglo-Saxon family-provision rules are treated as a functional equivalent of that mechanism;
  • if English law governs the succession, the compensatory levy should not apply, because the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 is such a protective mechanism;
  • the provision is meant to support Article 35 of the Succession Regulation (public-policy exception), not to impose French reserved shares whenever a foreign law differs.

The Commission considered the legal uncertainty resolved and later closed the file (closure notice dated 28 July 2026 on the same complaints page). In the same pre-closure notice, France reported that it would publish these explanations shortly in the monthly letter of the Direction des affaires civiles et du sceau (DACS) — a forthcoming civil-affairs circular, not a DACS issue already issued at the time of the Commission notice. Separately, the French authorities’ reading is already reflected online in the Service-Public fact sheet F606 — “Peut-on déshériter ses enfants ?”, including the compensatory levy.

English law vs most US state laws

For British nationals (and dual nationals) who validly elect English law, the French government reading is now clear and public: family provision counts, so the Article 913(3) levy should stay closed.

That reassurance does not automatically travel to every common-law system. Many US state succession regimes allow broad freedom of testation without a child-protective mechanism comparable to English family provision. Where the governing law truly offers no such mechanism, and the EU-link conditions are met, French assets can still be exposed to the compensatory levy. Each US state (or other non-EU law) must be assessed on its own terms — usually with a certificate of custom and a file-specific analysis.

Practical takeaways for international owners

  1. 1. Review wills written after the 2021 reform. A professio juris alone is no longer the whole story for French real estate.
  2. 2. Name the law carefully. “English law” and “the law of [US State]” are not interchangeable for Article 913(3).
  3. 3. Check the EU link. The levy only opens if the deceased or a child has EU nationality or habitual residence in the EU at death.
  4. 4. Treat the Commission notice as clarification, not a judgment of the Cour de cassation or the CJEU. Courts remain free to apply the statute to the facts of each estate.
  5. 5. Coordinate French and home-country advice before relying on any single planning document.

This is not a legal consultation. The law applicable to a property or succession in France must be verified on the individual file.

Sources (official)

  • Regulation (EU) No 650/2012 — EUR-Lex
  • Code civil, art. 913 al. 3 — Légifrance
  • European Commission notice CPLT(2022)03325 (pre-closure 4 June 2026; closure 28 July 2026) — France’s commitment to publish the explanations shortly in the DACS monthly letter
  • Service-Public F606 — “Peut-on déshériter ses enfants ?” (already online)
  • Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 — legislation.gov.uk