Anglo-American and other international couples often buy French real estate while still governed by a foreign matrimonial regime — English separation of property, a US prenuptial agreement, or no written contract at all. The deed at the French notary may name both spouses as purchasers, yet who owns the villa on divorce or death depends on a separate layer: the applicable matrimonial property law, not only the land register.
Since 29 January 2019, Council Regulation (EU) 2016/1103 has determined that law for participating EU Member States (including France), regardless of where assets are located. The Regulation does not replace French land law or notarial purchase formalities; it tells courts (and, in practice, notaries advising on liquidation) which national regime governs the economic relationship between spouses when French property must be divided or transmitted.
How the applicable matrimonial property law is chosen
Under Article 22 of Regulation 1103, spouses may choose only:
- the law of the State where either spouse is habitually resident at the time the agreement is concluded, or
- the law of the State of nationality of either spouse at that same moment.
If there is no valid choice, Article 26 sets a cascade of defaults: first the law of the first common habitual residence after the marriage, then their common nationality at the time the applicable law must be determined, then the law of the State with which the spouses jointly have the closest connection at the time.
That cascade bites when the “first home” was London or New York but the couple later settles in France. French community of property (communauté légale) may govern the liquidation of a Provençal house even if the spouses assumed their Anglo-American contract still controlled everything — especially where no French contrat de mariage was ever drawn up in the form required for cross-border effect.
Automatic change of law under the Hague Convention (pre-2019 marriages)
For many marriages concluded before 29 January 2019, the Hague Convention of 14 March 1978 still governs the matrimonial property regime when the analysis involves France and a State that applies the Convention (including ties with the United Kingdom). French law routes those cases through Article 1397-2 of the Civil Code, which applies the Convention’s designation and publicity rules in Articles 1397-3 and 1397-4 (Légifrance).
Unless the spouses have designated a different applicable law, the law initially chosen under the Convention continues to apply even if nationality or habitual residence changes (Article 7, first paragraph, Hague 1978). That is the default rule of immutability.
The second paragraph of Article 7 is different: where the spouses have neither designated the applicable law nor concluded a marriage contract, the internal law of the State where they both have their habitual residence can replace the previously applicable law — automatically, without a new agreement — in three situations listed in the Convention text:
- when that residence is established in that State and its nationality is their common nationality, or from the moment they become nationals of that State;
- when, after the marriage, that common habitual residence has lasted not less than ten years;
- when that residence is established in the cases where the regime was tied to common nationality only under Article 4(2)(3) of the Convention.
A change under Article 7(2) operates for the future only; property acquired before the change is not retroactively reclassified (Article 8, Hague 1978). A Contracting State may also require spouses to opt into national-law immutability by declaration (Article 5); check whether that declaration was made for the State concerned.
International buyers who “fixed” English or US law at the wedding but later made France their only common home should map this Hague logic before assuming the original default still governs the villa.
Form matters: Article 25 and the French notarial contract
A foreign prenuptial agreement or deed is not automatically effective in France. Article 25 of Regulation 1103 requires that matrimonial property agreements be made in writing, dated, and signed by both spouses. Where the chosen law is that of a participating Member State whose rules require a notarial form (as France does for contrats de mariage), that form must be respected.
The Service-Public guidance on marriage contracts — including cross-border warnings — is available in English as fact sheet F948.
Planning “we are separate under English law” without a French notarial act aligned with the chosen law is a common gap at the notary’s table when international buyers sign the compromis or the deed of sale.
Parallel proceedings: a conflict of jurisdictions
Regulation 1103 and Hague 1978 answer which national matrimonial property law applies. They do not by themselves prevent two courts in different countries from hearing the same divorce or financial remedy at the same time.
Spouses of any nationality may have concurrent actions before the courts of two States — for example a petition in one country and a divorce action in France — when the jurisdiction rules of each State are satisfied. That is a conflict of jurisdictions (which court may hear the case), distinct from a conflict of laws on the matrimonial regime (which national law governs the economic property regime).
Without early coordination, each forum may proceed on its own timetable. French immovable property remains subject to French registration and enforcement on the ground, but who divides what, and under which regime, still depends on the matrimonial property rules above — not on which divorce court speaks first.
Matrimonial property law is not divorce law
Do not conflate the two layers:
-
Matrimonial property regime (community, separation, etc.): for EU ties from 29 January 2019, Regulation 1103; for many earlier marriages, Hague 1978 and French implementing provisions. This is what governs liquidation of the economic regime affecting the villa.
-
Divorce (dissolution of the marriage, ancillary orders): jurisdiction follows instruments such as Regulation (EU) 2019/1111 (Brussels IIa) where it applies, and which law governs the divorce follows separate rules — notably Regulation (EU) No 1259/2010 (“Rome III”) for participating EU Member States.
United Kingdom withdrawal. Since the United Kingdom left the European Union, it no longer applies Regulation (EU) 2019/1111 or Rome III. A divorce connected with the United Kingdom and France needs its own jurisdictional and choice-of-law analysis. That point is limited to those EU divorce instruments. The cut-off of 29 January 2019 between the Hague Convention and Regulation 1103, set out above, applies to spouses of any nationality.
A divorce judgment rendered abroad does not automatically tell a French notary which matrimonial property law applies to a house in Provence. Conversely, choosing a law under Article 22 of Regulation 1103 does not settle where a divorce may be filed.
Practical takeaways before you sign
-
Separate the purchase deed from the matrimonial regime. Joint ownership on the acte authentique does not, by itself, tell you which law governs division on divorce or death.
-
Map the default under Article 26 (Regulation 1103) or Article 4 (Hague 1978). Where was the first common home after the wedding? Has habitual residence moved to France since?
-
For pre-2019 marriages, check Hague Article 7. If there was no designation of law and no marriage contract, a long-established common residence in France (or common French nationality on arrival) can shift the applicable matrimonial property law without a new deed.
-
If you choose a law, respect Article 25 form. English signatures on a US-style prenup rarely suffice for French immovable property without notarial adaptation.
-
Coordinate jurisdiction early. Concurrent actions before the courts of two States are a forum question for spouses of any nationality — align counsel before filing.
-
Keep divorce law and matrimonial property law on separate checklists. Rome III and Regulation 1103 / Hague 1978 serve different purposes.
-
Revisit on relocation. A move to France can shift habitual residence, Hague Article 7 defaults, and — under Regulation 1103 — the “closest connection” test; planning is not a one-off at the wedding.
This is not a legal consultation. The law applicable to a property or succession in France must be verified on the individual file.
Sources
- Council Regulation (EU) 2016/1103 — EUR-Lex (arts 22, 25, 26)
- Regulation (EU) No 1259/2010 (Rome III) — EUR-Lex
- Hague Convention of 14 March 1978 on matrimonial property regimes — HCCH (arts 4, 5, 7, 8)
- Code civil, arts 1397-2 to 1397-4 — Légifrance
- Service-Public F948 (English) — marriage contract and cross-border formalities